Can the VA Lower My Rating if I File a New Claim?

Looking for Expert-Level VA Claim Answers?📱Call Us Now! 737-295-2226

Yes, the VA can lower your disability rating if you file a new claim, but it doesn’t happen automatically. 

Filing a new claim may trigger a review of your existing conditions. In most cases, the VA won’t lower your rating unless there is clear evidence that your condition has improved. 

Here’s what you need to know before you file. 

Summary of Key Points

• Filing a new claim can trigger a review of your current ratings, but it doesn’t automatically lead to a reduction.  

• The VA must show sustained improvement and follow strict legal rules before lowering a rating.  

• For ratings in place 5 years or more, the VA generally can’t reduce based on one exam alone.  

• Rating protections increase at the 5-year, 10-year, and 20-year marks.  

• The risk depends on the type of claim you file and the strength of your evidence. 

When Can the VA Lower Your Rating After Filing a New Claim?

The VA may review your file when you submit a new claim, especially if it involves an existing service-connected condition. 

That review may include: 

• Your current ratings and past decisions  

• Medical records and treatment history  

• New evidence you submit  

• Results from a Compensation and Pension (C&P) exam  

If the VA believes your condition has improved, they may consider a reduction. However, they can’t lower your rating without meeting specific legal standards. 

For a full breakdown of when and how the VA can reduce your rating, see Can the VA Lower Your Disability Rating. 

Does Filing a New Claim Always Trigger a Review?

No. Filing a new claim doesn’t always trigger a full review of your existing ratings. 

However, the risk may increase if: 

• You file for an increased rating  

• You file for TDIU  

• Your new claim overlaps with an existing condition  

• The VA orders a new C&P exam  

In these cases, the VA is more likely to take a closer look at your current rating. 

The Legal Standard for VA Rating Reductions

Under 38 CFR § 3.344, the VA can’t reduce a stabilized rating without clear and consistent evidence. 

For ratings in place 5 years or more, the VA must show: 

• Sustained improvement over time, not a temporary change  

• Improvement under ordinary conditions of life and work  

• A full and complete examination, at least as thorough as the one used to assign the rating  

• Review of the entire medical history, not just a single exam  

In addition, the VA generally can’t reduce a rating based on one exam alone unless all evidence clearly supports improvement. If doubt remains, the VA is required to continue the current rating. 

VA Rating Protections to Know

Your rating becomes more protected the longer it has been in place.  

Examples include: 

• 5-Year Rule: After 5 years, your rating is considered more stable. The VA must show sustained improvement and cannot rely on one exam alone. 

• 10-Year Rule: After 10 years, your service connection is harder to take away in most cases. 

• 20-Year Rule: After 20 years, your rating generally can’t be reduced below that level except in cases like fraud. 

→ 7 Types of Protected VA Disability Ratings Explained 

What to Do If the VA Proposes a Reduction

If you receive a proposed reduction, act quickly. 

You may need to: 

• Submit new medical evidence  

• Challenge an inaccurate C&P exam  

• Show that no sustained improvement exists  

• Request a hearing  

The VA must review your response before making a final decision. 

→ How to Punch Back Against a Proposed VA Rating Reduction 

How to Increase Your VA Rating Without Risking a Reduction

Filing a new VA claim shouldn’t feel like a gamble. With the right evidence and strategy, you can pursue a VA rating increase without risking your current benefits. 

The difference comes down to how you file. Targeted claims, strong medical evidence, and the right strategy can increase your rating while limiting unnecessary exposure to review. Filing without a plan is where most veterans run into problems. 

Learn the most effective ways to increase your VA rating → 8 Proven Ways to Increase VA Disability Rating 

FAQs | Frequently Asked Questions

YOU SERVED. YOU DESERVE.

Do you have the VA rating you were given…or the VA rating you actually deserve?

Because getting a decision from the VA does not always mean you got the right decision from the VA.

If you are rated anywhere from 0% to 90% and feel stuck, frustrated, underrated, denied, or overlooked, I am speaking directly to you.

And if you have never filed because you thought other veterans deserved it more, because you got denied before, or because you assumed it was too late, do not let those myths make your decision for you.

At VA Claims Insider, we help underrated disabled veterans create real-life change by getting the VA rating and compensation they deserve!

Here’s a sliver of what you get when you join us:

• A Veteran Coach by your side, so you never have to fight the VA alone.

• A smarter, personalized strategy for your claim.

• Better VA disability education, so you know what to do next.

• Stronger private medical evidence (DBQs, Nexus Letters, Mental Health Evaluations, and more) at members-only rates to support the rating you deserve.

• And a proven battle plan toward VA claim victory.

But maybe you’re wondering: Will this actually work for me?

That is a fair question.

• At VA Claims Insider, we have helped 50,000+ veterans fight for the VA disability benefits they earned.

• Our internal data shows an average *33% VA rating increase for veterans who complete our Elite program.

• Our internal data also shows veterans in our programs get their claims approved *25% faster on average than the VA’s published average claim-processing timelines.

• Veterans in our community have left 7,000+ total reviews, with a 4.6 out of 5 average rating.

• More than 5,500 reviews are 5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐, and 92% of all veteran customer reviews are either 4 or 5 stars.

*Based on VA Claims Insider internal data for veterans who completed the Elite program. Average results shown; individual results vary. No guaranteed outcome or faster claim processing.

If you are ready for a better battle plan, a smarter strategy, and the right path to the VA rating and compensation you deserve, we’ve got your six.

📞 Call us now at 737-295-2226 or click the red button below to get started:

---

Content Reviewed By

About the Author