Can the VA Deny a Presumptive Disability Claim for Benefits?

Looking for Expert-Level VA Claim Help?📱Call Us Now! 737-295-2226

Yes, the VA can deny a presumptive disability claim for a variety of reasons.

Presumptive conditions are intended to make it easier for veterans to secure VA disability benefits by eliminating the need to directly prove a connection between their condition and military service.

However, approval is not automatic.

The VA requires veterans to meet specific eligibility criteria, including verifying a diagnosis of a presumptive condition and confirming their military service in a qualifying location and period as documented on the DD 214.

Failing to meet these requirements can result in a VA claim denial.

Even though presumptive VA claims simplify the process and are easier to win than other types of claims, veterans should still prepare thoroughly and provide accurate, complete documentation to maximize their chances of approval.

Pro Tip: Presumptive disability claims generally have higher approval rates than other types of claims, assuming you meet the eligibility criteria. For example, according to the VA’s PACT Act performance dashboard, PACT Act presumptive claims currently have a 74.5% approval rate (as of November 2024). That means three out of every four presumptive disability claims will be approved by the VA.

Summary of Key Points

• Yes, the VA Can Deny Presumptive Claims: While presumptive claims simplify the process of obtaining VA benefits by eliminating the need to directly prove service connection, approval is not automatic. Veterans must meet eligibility criteria, such as qualifying service locations, time periods, and having a diagnosed presumptive condition.

• Higher Approval Rates for Presumptive Disability: Presumptive claims generally have a higher approval rate compared to other types of claims. For example, PACT Act presumptive claims currently have a 74.5% approval rate, meaning nearly three out of four claims are approved.

• Common Reasons for Denial: Claims may be denied if there’s no current diagnosis of a presumptive condition, the condition is not on the VA’s presumptive list, service records do not show qualifying service, or clear evidence exists of a non-service-related cause for the condition.

• Action Steps After Denial: If a claim is denied, veterans should review their VA rating decision letter, ensure they have complete medical and service evidence, and file an appeal using options like a Higher-Level Review (HLR) or Supplemental Claim with new and relevant evidence. Persistence and thorough preparation are key to success.

What is a Presumptive Condition for VA Disability?

A presumptive disability is a condition that the VA automatically assumes is related to a veteran’s military service based on specific circumstances, such as the location and time period of service.

This eliminates the need for the veteran to prove a direct connection, or “nexus,” between their service and the condition they developed, making it easier to qualify for VA disability compensation benefits.

How Presumptive VA Disability Claims Work

Presumptive disability simplifies the process for veterans to receive VA benefits.

Here’s how it works:

• #1. Service in a Specific Location: The veteran must have served in a particular location known for hazardous exposures, such as areas with burn pits, Agent Orange, or other toxic substances. Examples include Vietnam during the war, certain parts of the Gulf War theater, or areas where veterans were exposed to radiation.

• #2. Qualifying Time Period: The veteran’s service must have occurred during a specific time frame when these exposures were known or suspected to occur.

• #3. Development of a Presumptive Condition: The veteran must have developed a medical condition that is recognized by the VA as being presumptively linked to the exposures in that location and time frame. These conditions are listed under the VA’s presumptive list and include various cancers, respiratory illnesses, and other serious health issues.

Evidence Requirements for Presumptive VA Disability Claims

Instead of needing to gather extensive medical evidence, including Nexus Letters, to prove that their condition was caused by their service, veterans only need to provide their military service records, such as their DD 214, showing they served in an eligible location during the qualifying period.

Veterans also need to have medical evidence of a current presumptive disability (diagnosed in medical records).

This streamlined process generally makes it easier and faster for veterans to receive the benefits they deserve.

Common Reasons for Denial of Presumptive Disability Claims

Here are the four most common reasons why the VA denies presumptive disability claims:

#1. No Diagnosis of a Current Presumptive Disability

The VA requires a current medical diagnosis of the presumptive condition to grant benefits.

Without a formal diagnosis, the claim lacks the necessary medical evidence.

Example: A veteran exposed to Agent Orange during service believes they have diabetes mellitus type 2, a presumptive condition. However, without a medical diagnosis confirming diabetes, the VA will deny the claim due to the absence of a current diagnosed disability.

#2. Your Disability is Not on the VA’s Presumptive List

The VA maintains a specific list of conditions presumed to be service-connected based on certain exposures or service locations.

If a veteran’s condition isn’t on this list, it doesn’t qualify for presumptive service connection.

Example: A veteran develops obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) after service and files a presumptive claim, but OSA isn’t on the VA’s presumptive list for their service period or exposure. Consequently, the VA can deny the claim because the disability is not eligible for presumptive VA benefits.

#3. Your DD 214 Does Not Show Qualifying Service at a Qualifying Location

The DD Form 214 documents a veteran’s service history.

If it doesn’t reflect service in locations or during periods associated with presumptive conditions, the VA may deny the claim.

Example: A veteran claims a presumptive condition linked to Gulf War service. However, their DD Form 214 doesn’t indicate deployment to the Southwest Asia theater of operations. Without evidence of qualifying service at a qualifying location for presumptive disability benefits, the VA can deny the claim.

#4. Clear Evidence of a Non-Service-Related Cause for the Disability

If the VA finds credible evidence that a disability resulted from non-service-related factors, it can rebut the presumption of service connection for disability benefits.

Example: A veteran develops a respiratory condition presumed to be linked to burn pit exposure. However, medical records reveal the condition is due to long-term civilian occupational exposure to industrial chemicals. The VA denies the claim, citing an alternative cause.

Action Steps to Take After a Presumptive VA Claim Denial

Step #1: Review Your VA Rating Decision Letter

The first step after a VA claim denial or underrating is to review your VA rating decision letter.

Pay particular attention to the reasons for decision and evidence reviewed sections.

A VA rating decision letter is a document prepared by the VA Rater that formally explains the VA’s rationale for approving, denying, or deferring your VA disability claim.

Your VA disability rating decision letter includes the VA’s final rating decision and analysis as well as why and how the VA Rater and C&P examiner arrived at their opinions and conclusions for your VA claim.

In my opinion, it’s the #1 most important document you’ll ever receive from the VA!

Step #2: Decide Your Best Appeal Option

The second step is to decide your best course of action to appeal the denied or underrated disability claim.

• If you had the right medical evidence but were denied due to an error or want a second opinion, file a VA Higher-Level Review (HLR).

• If you need to submit new and relevant evidence not previously considered, file a Supplemental Claim.

• If your Higher-Level Review, Supplemental Claim, and HLR of your Supplemental Claim are denied, consider a records-only Board Appeal.

Step #3: Review Your Medical Evidence

The third step before filing an appeal on your denied VA claim is to review the medical evidence you submitted with your original claim.

Match what you submitted with the evidence reviewed in your VA rating decision letter – make sure it’s accurate and consistent.

This is also a good time to confirm that you’ve provided the VA with:

• Medical records showing a current diagnosis of a presumptive disability,

• Your DD 214 verifying qualifying service at a qualifying location, and

• Medical evidence demonstrating the severity of your symptoms and their negative impact on your work, life, and social functioning.

If anything important was missing from your original claim, file a Supplemental Claim with the new and relevant evidence not previously considered.

Step #4: File Your VA Appeal Online

The final step to challenge a denied or underrated VA claim decision is to file your VA Higher Level Review (HLR) or Supplemental Claim online.

Friendly reminder that you can’t submit new and relevant evidence with a Higher-Level Review (HLR), but you can with a Supplemental Claim.

After submission, be proactive, patient, and don’t ever give up!

The VA claim process isn’t over unless you quit.

There’s always another option if you’re willing to punch back.

Want Expert-Level Help with Your VA Disability Claim? WE GOT YOUR SIX!

How does VA Claims Insider help veterans?

We make the confusing and frustrating VA claim process EASY through our 8-step proprietary system and one-on-one coaching; we’re the VA Claim EXPERTS you can trust, and YOU are never alone in this fight against the VA!

You’ll also receive VA disability expert Brian Reese’s SEM Method Blueprint—a proven formula that has helped over 25,000 veterans win their VA disability claims faster:

Strategy + Education + Medical Evidence = VA Rating and Compensation You Deserve FASTER!

Start today and unlock an exceptional level of service you deserve for serving our country:

➡️ You’ll hear from a VA Claim Expert over email within 15 minutes of signing up today.

➡️ You’ll hear from your Veteran Coach team within 24 hours of all inquiries during normal business days/hours.

➡️ Our terms are clear and simple: If we don’t win, you don’t pay. You have nothing to lose and everything to gain.

Click the red button below to start the process of winning your VA claim right now!

Veterans: Are You Ready to WIN, SERVICE-CONNECT, and INCREASE Your VA Rating FASTER? We Can Help!

• VA Claims Insider is the #1 most trusted name in VA disability claims.

• Work directly with a VA claims coach who can help lead you to VA claim victory.

• 25,000+ disabled veterans served in our membership programs since 2016.

• 30% average rating increase for veterans who complete our #1 rated Elite program.

• 4.7/5.0 average rating out of 5,500+ total reviews; over 4,500 5-star reviews.

About the Author