When filing a VA disability claim, the strength and quality of the evidence you present play a crucial role in determining whether your claim is approved or denied.

The VA relies heavily on the “probative value” of evidence to assess whether your claim is compelling enough to grant VA disability benefits.

But what does probative value mean, and how can you ensure that your evidence meets the VA’s standards?

In this article, we’ll break down the key concepts you need to understand to maximize the impact of your evidence and improve your chances of VA claim victory.

Summary of Key Points

Understanding Probative Value: Probative value is the strength and relevance of evidence in making a fact more or less likely to be true, particularly in establishing the service connection for a VA disability claim. The evidence must be compelling, credible, and relevant to support the claim effectively.

Factors Affecting Probative Value: The VA evaluates evidence based on competency (qualifications of the source), credibility (believability), thoroughness (completeness), precision (specificity), and relevance (relation to the claimed condition). The date of the evidence also influences its weight, with more recent records typically carrying greater probative value.

High vs. Low Probative Value: Evidence with high probative value includes well-supported independent medical opinions, recent medical records, and consistent lay statements that align with documented facts. Evidence with low probative value includes vague or outdated opinions, conflicting evidence without explanation, and reports from unqualified sources.

Tips for Strengthening Evidence: To increase the probative value, submit a strong nexus letter with detailed reasoning, ensure all evidence is consistent, use recent and relevant medical documentation, and include statements from qualified professionals or credible lay sources.

What is Probative Value for VA Disability Claims?

Probative value refers to the ability of a piece of evidence to make a fact or issue more or less likely to be true.

According to M21-1, evidence has probative value for your VA claim if it:

Makes a matter material to the determination more or less likely, and

Has sufficient weight, either by itself or in combination with other evidence, to persuade the decision maker about a fact.

In the context of VA claims, it means the weight and persuasiveness of the evidence in establishing that a veteran’s condition is connected to their military service.

Simply put, for evidence to have probative value, it must be relevant to the claim and persuasive enough to help the VA decide in your favor.

Evidence with high probative value can include Service Treatment Records (STRs), expert independent medical opinions, and credible lay statements that directly support your VA disability claim.

How the VA Determines the Probative Value of Evidence

The VA evaluates several factors when determining the probative value of evidence.

These considerations help establish the weight and impact of the evidence presented:

Competency: The evidence must come from a qualified source. For medical evidence, the source should be a licensed healthcare professional capable of diagnosing medical conditions or offering clinical opinions. Lay evidence can also be competent if the person has direct knowledge of the facts, such as firsthand observations of your condition’s impact.

Credibility: The believability of the evidence is crucial. The VA assesses whether the evidence is consistent with other records and whether the source has any biases. Evidence that contradicts established facts or seems implausible will have less probative value.

Thoroughness: Detailed and comprehensive evidence carries more weight. Incomplete or vague information is not sufficient to support a claim effectively. Evidence should address all relevant aspects of the claim.

Precision: The accuracy of the evidence, such as specific clinical findings, enhances its probative value. Precise measurements, dates, or detailed accounts add credibility.

Relevance: The evidence must directly relate to the condition being claimed. Irrelevant information does not help prove the issue in question, even if it is from a credible source.

Date of the Evidence: The recency of the evidence matters, as more recent records typically better reflect the current state of your condition. Older evidence may carry less weight if it does not accurately represent the present severity of the disability.

Evaluating the Probative Value of Medical Evidence for Your VA Claim

When assessing medical evidence, the VA also considers additional elements:

Physician’s Qualifications and Experience: The specialist’s training, certifications, and familiarity with the veteran’s condition can affect the weight given to their opinion.

Knowledge of Relevant History: An understanding of the veteran’s service and past medical history strengthens the probative value of the opinion.

Clinical Testing and Reasoning: Opinions backed by clinical tests, observations, and sound medical principles carry more weight. The physician should explain how the veteran’s condition is linked to service.

Degree of Specificity and Certainty: Medical opinions should provide specific conclusions and a clear level of certainty to increase their probative value.

Examples of Probative and Non-Probative VA Claim Evidence

Evidence with High Probative Value:

A Nexus Letter from a licensed healthcare provider that states, ‘It is at least as likely as not’ that the veteran’s condition is related to service, and is supported by clinical data and medical research, carries high probative value. Expert opinions that are well-written and evidence-based significantly enhance the strength of your VA disability claim.

Recent and Relevant Medical Records that document a current diagnosis, symptoms, and treatment for the claimed condition.

Competent and Credible Lay Statements that consistently describe the impact of the veteran’s condition on daily life and match the facts in medical records.

Evidence with Low or No Probative Value:

Opinions from Unqualified Sources, such as a non-medical professional offering a diagnosis or medical opinion.

Vague Medical Opinions that do not provide a rationale or fail to explain how the condition is connected to military service.

Conflicting Evidence Without Explanation: For example, a medical report that contradicts other records without a detailed rationale for the discrepancy.

Outdated Records that do not reflect the veteran’s current condition or do not support ongoing disability.

Treating Physician’s Opinion vs. Independent Medical Opinions

The VA does not automatically favor a treating physician’s medical opinion over an expert’s independent medical opinion.

However, a treating physician who is familiar with the veteran’s medical history may provide a more compelling opinion due to their understanding of the condition’s progression and connection to service.

To strengthen an opinion’s probative value, the physician should offer a thorough explanation supported by clinical evidence.

Supporting Medical Opinions with Evidence

For medical conclusions to have high probative value, they must be well-supported by facts, clinical testing, and relevant records.

Citing medical treatises, scientific data, or independent medical opinions can enhance the probative strength.

Opinions should connect the evidence to the conclusions reached, making a compelling case for service connection.

Credibility of a Veteran’s Own Medical History

Medical assessments often rely on the veteran’s account of their history.

While the VA generally accepts the veteran’s history as credible, inconsistencies or inaccuracies can reduce the probative value.

An opinion that simply repeats the veteran’s history without medical rationale lacks sufficient probative weight.

Tips for Increasing the Probative Value of Your Evidence

Submit a Strong Nexus Letter: The letter should state that the condition is “at least as likely as not” related to military service or another disability and provide detailed, evidence-based rationale.

Use Competent Medical and Lay Evidence: Present statements from qualified medical professionals and lay witnesses (non-experts such as family, friends, and buddies) who can credibly attest to your condition, why it should be service-connected, your severity of symptoms, and how it negatively impacts your work, life, and social functioning.

Ensure Consistency Across Evidence: Avoid contradictions between your statements and medical records. Your VA disability claim evidence should be consistent to maintain the credibility and probative value.

Provide Recent and Relevant Medical Records: Up-to-date documentation of the condition carries more weight. For example, a current diagnosis has more probative value than a diagnosis from 10-years ago.

Conclusion & Wrap-Up

The probative value of evidence is vital for a successful VA disability claim.

The stronger and more persuasive the evidence, the better your chances of establishing a service connection.

By focusing on providing competent, credible, and detailed evidence, you can increase the likelihood of a favorable decision.

If you need help with your claim, VA Claims Insider can guide you through every step to ensure your evidence meets the VA’s standards.

Remember, the VA aims to grant benefits where supported by the evidence—make your claim as robust as possible!

VA Probative Value: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is probative value in the context of VA disability claims?

Probative value refers to the ability of a piece of evidence to make a fact more or less likely to be true. In VA disability claims, it is used to assess how persuasive the evidence is in proving a connection between a veteran’s condition and their military service. The more relevant and convincing the evidence, the higher its probative value.

2. Why is probative value important for my VA disability claim?

Probative value is crucial because the VA uses it to determine whether the evidence submitted can support a claim for benefits. Evidence with high probative value strengthens a claim, making it more likely for the VA to decide in favor of the veteran. Conversely, evidence with little or no probative value may not effectively support the claim.

3. How does the VA determine the probative value of evidence?

The VA considers several factors when determining the probative value of evidence, including the competency of the source, credibility, thoroughness, precision, relevance, and the date of the evidence. Each of these factors contributes to the overall weight and persuasiveness of the evidence.

4. What factors affect the probative value of evidence?

Several factors influence probative value, including:

Competency: The source’s qualifications to provide the evidence.
Credibility: The believability and consistency of the evidence.
Thoroughness: The detail and completeness of the evidence.
Precision: The accuracy and specificity of the information.
Relevance: The direct relation to the issue being addressed.
Date of the evidence: More recent evidence is usually more valuable.

5. Can lay evidence have probative value in a VA disability claim?

Yes, lay evidence can have probative value if the individual providing it has firsthand knowledge of the facts and their testimony is consistent with other evidence on record. However, it may carry less weight compared to medical evidence provided by a qualified professional.

6. How does the VA evaluate medical evidence for probative value?

When assessing medical evidence, the VA looks at factors such as the physician’s qualifications, familiarity with the veteran’s medical history, reasoning used in the medical opinion, and whether clinical tests support the conclusions. Opinions that are detailed and well-reasoned generally have higher probative value.

7. What is the difference between competent and credible evidence?

Competent evidence refers to information provided by someone qualified to give an opinion on the matter, such as a licensed medical professional for medical conditions. Credible evidence, on the other hand, is believable and consistent with other available information. Both factors contribute to the probative value of evidence.

8. Does the VA automatically give more weight to a treating physician’s opinion?

No, the VA does not apply the “treating physician rule” and does not automatically give more weight to a treating physician’s opinion. However, a treating physician’s familiarity with the veteran’s medical history may increase the probative value of their opinion if the evidence is consistent and well-supported.

9. What role does the date of evidence play in determining probative value?

The date of the evidence matters because more recent information typically reflects the veteran’s current condition more accurately. Older evidence may carry less weight if it does not represent the present state of the disability.

10. Can the absence of evidence impact the probative value of a VA claim?

Yes, the absence of evidence can be considered when there is a reasonable expectation that such documentation would be present. However, it cannot be used as substantive negative evidence against the claim unless there is a basis in the record to demonstrate that the lack of documentation has a tendency to disprove a fact.

11. How is the probative value of conflicting evidence evaluated?

When evidence conflicts, the VA considers the qualifications of the sources, the thoroughness of their opinions, and consistency with other facts in the record. If the evidence is in relative equipoise, meaning it is evenly balanced, the benefit of the doubt goes to the veteran.

12. What is the “reasonable doubt rule” in VA claims?

The reasonable doubt rule states that if the evidence for and against a claim is evenly balanced, the VA will resolve the doubt in favor of the veteran. This approach ensures that veterans are given the benefit of any uncertainty when the probative value of evidence is in question.

13. What makes evidence non-probative in a VA claim?

Evidence is considered non-probative if it is not credible, comes from an unqualified source, or does not directly relate to the issue being claimed. Additionally, vague opinions without supporting rationale or evidence that contradicts established facts may be deemed non-probative.

14. How can I increase the probative value of my evidence?

To enhance the probative value of your evidence, ensure that it is:

Provided by qualified professionals.
Detailed and includes a thorough rationale.
Consistent with other records and facts.
Up-to-date and relevant to your current condition.

15. Can negative evidence affect my claim’s outcome?

Yes, negative evidence can weaken a claim by suggesting that the condition is not related to military service or by contradicting positive evidence. For example, a lack of documentation supporting the condition’s onset during service can be considered negative evidence.

16. Does the VA consider medical treatises or scientific articles as probative evidence?

Yes, medical treatises and scientific articles can be used to support medical opinions in a claim, especially if they establish a link between the veteran’s condition and military service. Their probative value is stronger when cited alongside specific case facts.

17. What should a medical opinion include to be considered probative?

A probative medical opinion should include:

Specific medical conclusions.
A clear rationale and supporting evidence.
Connections to general medical principles and the veteran’s records.
A thorough explanation of how the condition is related to military service.

18. How does the VA weigh evidence from non-VA sources?

Evidence from non-VA sources is weighed objectively, just like VA-originated evidence. It is assessed for competency, credibility, and probative value. The VA does not automatically consider non-VA evidence as having less probative value.

19. Can a veteran’s personal statements be considered probative?

Yes, a veteran’s personal statements can be probative if they provide firsthand knowledge of events or symptoms that are consistent with other evidence in the claim. However, personal interest in the outcome may affect the credibility of such statements.

20. What is the significance of the burden of proof in determining probative value?

The burden of proof in VA claims is typically the “as likely as not” standard, meaning the evidence must show that it is at least as likely as not that the condition is service-connected. The probative value of evidence plays a crucial role in meeting this standard and determining whether the claim is granted.

About the Author

Brian Reese

Brian Reese is a world-renowned VA disability benefits expert and the #1 bestselling author of VA Claim Secrets and You Deserve It. Motivated by his own frustration with the VA claim process, Brian founded VA Claims Insider to help disabled veterans secure their VA disability compensation faster, regardless of their past struggles with the VA. Since 2013, he has positively impacted the lives of over 10 million military, veterans, and their families.

A former active-duty Air Force officer, Brian has extensive experience leading diverse teams in challenging international environments, including a combat tour in Afghanistan in 2011 supporting Operation ENDURING FREEDOM.

Brian is a Distinguished Graduate of Management from the United States Air Force Academy and earned his MBA from Oklahoma State University’s Spears School of Business, where he was a National Honor Scholar, ranking in the top 1% of his class.

0 Shares